Tag Archives: Utah

Buttars’ Bill on Freedom of Religious Expression

I think it’s time for another round of Beavers and Buttars, only on a different topic.

This year, Utah Senator Chris Buttars (R-West Jordan) is introducing legislation (SB111)that would permit individuals to express religious messages on public property while still prohibiting government entities from imposing religious concepts.
Today’s Deseret News describes Buttars’ bill where Buttars is quoted as stating that it would be o.k., for example, for a student to walk into school with a religious message on a t-shirt.

Buttars said his bill would apply to a student wearing a T-shirt with a religious message to school or a group singing a Christmas hymn in a public park — but not a government entity that wants to put up a Nativity scene. High school students would be able to choose to pray at their graduation, he said, but the school couldn’t make that part of the event.
“That’s the separation of church and state I believe in,” the senator said. “That government officials can’t impose religion on individuals, but individuals have the right to express closely held religious beliefs on public property.”

Buttars said he introduced the bill after a student was sent home with an LDS message on a t-shirt and feels that students should be able to express their religious beliefs.

Well, then, let’s consider these scenarios:
A student from an LDS family has a t-shirt with: “CTR”
Another student from an atheist family has a t-shirt with “There is no God”
And another student from a Catholic church has a t-shirt with “Homosexuality is a sin”.
Yet another student from a Church of the Creator family has a t-shirt with “Kill All Blacks”

Under Buttars’ bill, all of the above would be permissible.

While I feel that students have the right to bring their bibles with them, pray to themselves in school, etc., the line gets drawn when messages are blatantly displayed, interrupting the learning process and making others feel uncomfortable as well.

This is a bill that is an unnecessary piece of legislation – something Buttars is good at doing.

This week’s Utah Legislature Headlines

Deseret News
Lobbyists wiggle through loophole
Schools rehiring retirees: Districts are desperate due to teacher shortage
Utah’s gas tax may change: And 1 bill would cut $$ going to transit districts
Utahns are still split over vouchers: But poll finds support gaining for tuition aid
State wants to increase movie incentive fund
Buttars seeks free exercise of faith
Cap is proposed on part of tuition that pays faculty

Salt Lake Tribune
Republican prepares bill for demise of Roe v. Wade
Governor says he will fight to keep in-state tuition: Despite veto threat, bill’s sponsor will push to repeal lower college rates for immigrants
4 of 5 USTAR outreach centers selected
Soccer plan: New concerns
Consultant raises questions about RSL’s debt load, cash flow

Guv wants to tweak anti-meth efforts–Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. unveils a $10.2 million campaign focusing on prevention and rehab
Rise in minimum wage OK’d by House–Utah representatives are divided along party lines; Senate plans tax breaks for businesses

Divine Strake “public meetings”

Last night was the Salt Lake session sponsored by the feds on the Divine Strake Test at the Grand America Hotel in Salt Lake City.
I stood outside with a few others with protest signs and handed out literature. As soon as we arrived we were approached by hotel security and told we couldn’t be there with our signs. We promptly told him we could be on the sidewalk because it is public property. He tried to tell us we need a license to do that, to which Tom replied:
(stepping on hotel sidewalk block)This is Grand America. (stepping on public sidewalk)This is America, land of the free where we have the right to exercise our freedom of expression.”

That shut him up.

We took turns going inside, although I chose to stay outside the whole time.
Everyone I talked to going in and out was opposed to the test. One man inside caused an uproar when had yelled out for those opposed to the test to say so (to which the entire room did). He was escorted out (go Kevin Donahue!).

We all were interviewed by the media. Tom’s quote got into the Deseret News (link to article below):
“My primary concern is for the well-being of life on this planet,” said Tom King, Salt Lake City. Besides damage from radioactive isotopes at the test site, he said, he is worried about the government’s intentions.
“They want to see what a little nuke will do to underground facilities,” King said.

The governor has set dates for hearings:
Governor sets Divine Strake hearings

Articles in today’s news about the meeting:
Divine Strake session criticized
Divine Strake visitors frustrated
‘Divine Strake’ meeting draws small but boisterous crowd
Meeting Regarding Explosion Draws Big Crowd
Divine Strake Hearing Draws Hundreds



Utah Legislative News

Deseret News

Speed-limit hike opposed
Lawmakers considering plan to cut property tax: GOP leaders look at plan to trim surpluses
Ag chief offers hints on farm bill
Driver-safety bills in Utah Legislature
Lawmakers urged to focus on health care: Group asks Utahns to visit the Capitol to push for action
Majority of Utahns favor big tax cuts
Don’t kill tuition break(Opinion)
Child-care providers may face new rules

Salt Lake Tribune
Gastric surgery: Bill would mandate that insurance pay

More government mandates

I am really tired of the government using tax dollars to make laws that are very hard to enforce and just don’t make a lot of sense.

I am not a smoker. However, I am not a “holier-than-thou” non-smoker. I feel everyone has the right to do whatever they want to their own bodies. I also feel that there is a responsibility that goes with that right and that is to be sure that others’ rights are being honored.

Having said that, I do not agree with the recently implemented new law in Salt Lake City which mandates that smokers may not smoke in any public park. No exceptions.
So that means that if someone who smokes is standing by a tree in a public park with no one in sight around her/him, and chooses to smoke, she/he could get a citation. This law is an “all or nothing” law which I feel is highly unrealistic. It would have made much more sense to implement a policy which was no smoking within 25 or 50 feet of a gathering in a public park.

So let’s see then. It seems that this law is designed to collectively punish those who are addicted by choice to something that has potential harm to others. Okay……I want our lawmakers, then, to outlaw driving. The pollution from cars is far more harmful than the smoke from a single cigarrette. Not to mention the hazards of possibly being hit by a car when crossing the street and the inhalation of fumes as one waits on a corner waiting to cross the street. Folks who are addicted to driving cars will just have to up and quit!

So if our lawmakers are going to make laws designed to protect people, get with it and be equitable – protect people from all pollutants, not just one.

Stop the Divine Strake Hearings

Next week there will be National Nuclear Security Agency and the Defense Threat Reduction Agency “public hearings” on the Divine Strake Test in Nevada and Utah (schedule below) – only they aren’t really “hearings” but, rather, “poster shows”. While written comments will be accepted, the public will not be permitted to make public comment at these “hearings”.

The Stop the Divine Strake Coalition, of which I am a member, brainstormed last week on how the public would be able to vocally voice comments on the DS Test. We decided that organizing and holding our own hearings was necessary and have proceeded to organize them. We plan to videotape the hearings and send them to the DTRA.

One of the coalition members contacted Utah Governor Huntsman’s office to see if he would agree to hold a public hearing.

He agreed.

Today’s Salt Lake Tribune and Deseret News have articles on the Governor’s acceptance of the concept of holding a hearing:
Guv wants Utah to have a say
State will hold its own public hearings to allow residents to express Divine Strake concerns

Huntsman orders 2 hearings on ‘Strake’

Schedule of next week’s Federal Government “hearings”:

  • Tuesday, January 9th, 6:30 pm – Cashman Center – Las Vegas, NV –
    for more info call Nevada Desert Experience (702) 646-4814 or Citizen
    Alert (702) 796-5662

  • Wednesday, January 10th, 6:30 pm – Energy Solutions Arena – Salt
    Lake City, UT – for more info call HEAL Utah (801) 355-5055

  • Thursday, January 11th, 6:30 pm – Dixie Center – St. George, UT

    The Defense Threat Reduction Agency and the National Nuclear Security Agency will also accept comments on the environmental assessment through Feb. 7. They should be mailed to NNSA/NSO, Divine Strake EA Comments, P.O. Box 98518, Las Vegas, NV 89193-8518, or e-mailed to divinestrake@nv.doe.gov or faxed to 702-295-0625.

    CANCEL THE DIVINE STRAKE! STOP WEAPONS TESTING ON ANY LAND! END NUCLEAR PROLIFERATION!

  • Still a Lot of Work to do

    Today’s Deseret News has published an opinion poll showing the Utah’s ratings of Bush and Cheney are far higher than the national poll figures.

    Boy, do we still have a lot of work to do.

    Photo (Deseret Morning News graphic)
    Deseret Morning News graphic

    Utah Legislative News

    Deseret News
    Real S.L. may seek state funds: Sandy pondering a bill to create new funding
    Measure could cut Medicaid costs: SB42 would create a list of preferred prescription drugs

    Salt Lake Tribune
    Delegates gather to select replacement for Rep. Jeff Alexander

    Today’s Utah Legislative News

    Deseret News
    Valentine says UVSC should be university: Senate chief is making that his session priority
    Provo House vacancy filled: State GOP chief selects developer for District 62
    United Way expanding role in public-policy arena

    Salt Lake Tribune
    RSL funds far from a done deal
    ‘We have not yet made any commitments,’ says investor

    Utah Legislature

    Today’s Utah Legislative News:

    Deseret News
    ’07 Legislature to wrestle few ‘moral bills’
    Lawmakers to weigh school-district splits
    Immigration bill on docket again
    House seat up in air:
    Change in law creates confusion on how to fill Alexander’s former post

    Salt Lake Tribune
    Ex-Huntsman staffer may battle Cannon: Republican Jason Chaffetz says the GOP wasted an opportunity when they had it
    Plans are in motion to get UVSC university status: Graduate programs and a new library need to be in place by 2008 in order to qualify