Tag Archives: Utah

PFS Determined to Move Forward

Private Fuel Storage, a consoritum of utility companies who now obtain a license to build a nuclear waste storage facility on the Goshute Reservation in Skull Valley in western Utah, has made it clear thatit will move forward and opponents can’t stop them, and in fact is downplaying any efforts being made by citizens in Utah, including the state of Utah.

“We will get the fuel to the site because it’s a legal commodity, and we now have a license to receive it,” said Private Fuel Storage’s chairman John Parkyn.

Really?

And get this:

Parkyn said the Cedar Mountain reserve is not a real wilderness either, arguing that the wilderness is in the mountains and that the delegation just “drew a bubble” around the mountains to block the nuclear waste — an argument he says could matter later down the line.

Not real wilderness? What does that mean? So now the PFS chair is an expert in wilderness issues?

The state of Utah this week filed an updated challenge to the PFS proposal in the U.S. District Court of Appeals for Washington, D.C. It challenges the NRC’s license, issued to PFS last month.

And Time magazine is reporting that PFS would pay the Skull Valley Band of Goshute Indians up to $100 million over 40 years for the right to operate its proposed repository on the band’s reservation.

Jason Groenewold, director of the anti-nuclear group Healthy Environment Alliance of Utah, said the $100 million figure is “pennies on the dollar, compared to liabilities the nuclear industry faces for keeping this waste where it’s generated. . . .
“Given that the liabilities and risks are going to be the highest for those that live in Skull Valley, they got the short end of the stick.”

(You can view the Time Magazine article at Utah’s Toxic Opportunity: SOME GOSHUTE INDIANS WANT TO CREATE A NUCLEAR-FUEL DUMP ON THEIR LAND. CONTROVERSIAL? OF COURSE)

The PFS site would be a 40 year project to store up to half the nation’s spent fuel rods from nuclear energy facilities. After 40 years PFS would leave the project and there are no plans to maintain the site after that. Spent fuel/toxic waste takes tens of thousands of years to reach the point being “harmless” to life.

It will be interesting to see if PFS chairman Parkyn gets his way. There is a lot of resistance to this project in our state and their are people who are willing to put their bodies on the line to do everything they can from preventing this project to move forward – including me.

Good resources to reasearch and find more info in this issue are:

HEAL Utah
Shundahai Network

(Dee’s ‘Dotes posts on PFS)

Hill Happenings

Follow-up on Legislature 2006: Articles in published in today’s Utah newspapers:

Salt Lake Tribune
Senate killed bills on ethical standard–Resisting reform: Implication of impropriety angered some
Analyst says docs’ shield law won’t stand up in courtroom
Lawmakers ignored learning gap in 2006, education advocates say: Legislators ignored achievement

Deseret News
Land-use bill raises ethics questions

It’s Official: Campaign Season Has Begun

Today is the first day of a 10 day window that candidates can file for office in Utah. All 75 House Seats and 16 of the 29 Senator seats area up for grabs.

Today’s Deseret News has an article on what Senators seats are open.

The Green Party will be running candidates this year and will announce them after its 2006 nominating convention being held this week.

A special nominating convention was held in the fall for the U.S. Senate race (Orrin Hatch’s seat). Elected for candidacy was Julian Hatch.

These offices are up for election this year, along with their term of office and filing fee. For more information on requirements, visit the State Elections Office Website and for Salt Lake County offices, visit the Salt Lake County Elections Website.

Federal and State Offices

  • U.S. Senate (Hatch)
    6 years ,$1,160

  • U.S. House Districts 1, 2 and 3
    2 years, $387

  • State Senate Districts 2,3,4,5,7,9,11,12,15,17,18,21,22,24,26,28
    4 Year,$32.40

  • State House Districts 1-75
    2 Year, $16.20

  • State School Board Districts 2,3,5,6,9,10,14,15
    4 Year, $15.00

    County Offices

  • Salt Lake County Council At-Large C
    6 Year, $229.85

  • Salt Lake County Council (1,3,5)
    4 Year, $153.23

  • Salt Lake County Assessor
    4 Year, $574.92

  • Salt Lake County Auditor
    4 Year, $632.04

  • Salt Lake County Clerk
    4 Year, $580.20

  • Salt Lake County District Attorney
    4 Year, $712.32

  • Salt Lake County Recorder
    4 Year, $580.20

  • Salt Lake County Sheriff
    4 Year, $590.28

  • Salt Lake County Surveyor
    4 Year, $574.92

  • Salt Lake County Treasurer
    4 Year, $574.92

  • District School Boards-(Salt Lake City -Precincts 3,4,6;Murray-Precincts 2,3,4;
    Granite-Precincts 3,5,6,7;Jordan-Precincts 1,2,3,6)
    4 Year, $25.00

  • Judicial Retention Courts of Record
    4 Year, $50.00

  • County Justice Court Judges
    4 Year, $25.00

  • Townships
    4 Year, $10.00

  • Hill Happenings – Follow Up on Legislative Actions

    Articles in published in today’s Utah newspapers about Utah Legislature news:

    Deseret News
    Students picking up slack with tuition hike: U. levy to increase 10%, Dixie’s to rise up to 30%

    Utah Navajos Sue State of Utah

    The state of Utah and Southern Utah Navajos entered into a contract in 1956 which would provide services to the nation and its people in exchange for the right by the state to drill for oil, inclusive of digging up burial grounds.

    The lawsuit states that the drinking water from once used local springs is unsafe to drink and that royalty money from 1955 to 1990 was not used the way it was contracted to be to benefit the Navajo people, to provide infrastructure, education, electiricty and other services.

    For the past 15 years, Utah’s Navajos have been asking the state to account for how the money was spent – or pay some $150 million back into the trust fund.
    In January, a federal judge gave the case a nudge forward by ruling the state must account for how the funds were spent in those years.
    Assistant attorney general Phil Lott plans to appeal the judge’s recent decision.
    “Until we get to the point where we can determine the number of years the state may be responsible for and where the state may have responsibility to pay, it’s impossible to . . . write a check and settle the case,” he said. “It’s not to be difficult or drag the case out, it’s that the state is responsible to protect the taxpayers’ money.”

    Representing the tribe and its interests is Utah civil rights attorney Brian Barnard. Barnard states that because the state is creating a case of strong resistance, this lawsuit could take 2-3 years, according to the Salt Lake Tribune article.

    According to the Aneth Chapter of the Navajo Nation, Jamie Harvey, In Aneth, 15 percent of the population has water, while the waiting lists for electricity and water funded by the chapter are years long. Many don’t understand the mammoth hurdles to extending power and water, Harvey said. Archeological studies must be done. There are materials and construction costs. And then there are maintenance costs.
    Each project must go through the Navajo Nation itself, which in the past has told Utah’s Navajos to look to their trust fund for money.

    The land that was once thriving with plant life and freshwater springs now has exposed, rotted in places pipeline, is sparse with plants and in place of springs there are murky pools of water with an oil cap jutting from the ground.

    State attorneys want to appeal a recent ruling in favor of Utah Navajos. On April 27, a Utah federal judge will consider how much detail the state must provide in an accounting of funds spent in the past.

    Sources for more information and from differing perspectives:
    Navajo Nation Council
    Independent Web Edition
    Shundahai Network
    The Political Mark Markboy
    High Country News
    Associated Press Article in Indian Country Today
    State of Utah
    Sate of Utah Government site

    Hill Happenings

    Articles in published in today’s Utah newspapers about Utah Legislature news:

    Salt Lake Tribune
    Senate killed bills on ethical standards: Resisting reform: Implication of impropriety angered some
    Tax cut faded as chaos hit session–2006 legislative session: The last-minute breakdown showed crack in alliances

    Hill Happenings

    Articles in published in today’s Utah newspapers about Utah Legislature news:

    Salt Lake Tribune
    Lawmakers follow public will on majority of issues
    Bill to hit plaintiffs for cash irks EPA–Unconstitutional? Feds share the governor’s doubts about forcing suitors to pay for project delays they cause

    Deseret News
    The soccer boondoggle– Opinion
    Lawmakers are self-serving kings of the Hill– Opinion
    Waiting for Huntsman’s signature
    Board of Education seeking 2 vetoes: College-credit fees and charter school measure opposed
    Counseling, voting bills to benefit military: 6 measures to affect armed forces pass while 11 others fail
    EPA voices concern over environmental-bond bill: Huntsman delays signing, will review it for possible problems

    Hill Happenings

    Articles in published in today’s Utah newspapers about Utah Legislature news:

    Salt Lake Tribune
    Tax overhaul top issue for special session–2006 Legislature review: Not so fast: The regular session may have ended late Wednesday night, but with so much unresolved business, the governor says
    Huntsman hints at veto of bill on suits–HB100: Governor cites constitutionality issues over environmentalists going to court to stop projects
    Schools secession is in the air–S. Salt Lake may lead defectors from Granite District after HB77 is signed
    New law: Cities get first crack at surplus schools
    Legacy plans show product of cooperation: Open houses offer a graphic preview of the historic route
    Wheels in motion on deal to get trains off 900 South
    Mayors back flood plan but not tax hike
    Radiation-fallout compensation reaches $1 billion
    Wendover deal buried in the desert: $27 million in red: The gambling town won’t join its Utah twin unless it’s debt-free
    U.S. House panel backs Cannon’s bill on privacy for phone records
    Council’s benefits plan: Is it legal? Traditional marriage: Gay community wants a court ruling to test laws

    Deseret News
    The year of the governor – Opinion
    Tax-reform session planned–Huntsman to call lawmakers back soon to ‘complete the deal’
    Ground finally broken for Legacy
    Utah gets a D on mental health report card: Lack of funding is called state’s biggest problem
    Huntsman is urged to veto second waste bill: HB100 violates Utah’s constitution, groups say
    Moral bills had tough time this year: Demo laments lack of action to help ‘vulnerable’ Utahns
    Death of bill may free up expanded insurance in Salt Lake

    2006 Utah Legislature Hits and Misses

    The 2006 Utah Legislative session is over. Tom and I went to the capitol last night for about 45 minutes during the last 5 hours of the session. The place was “a-buzz” with citizens and legislatures alike. Supporters of various bills maintained a vigilant presence up until the final vote.

    Here is my inital attempt at a personal “hits and misses” bills list (which bills I like and which I didn’t) of this year’s session:

    Hits:
    HB90 Criminal Penalty Amendments, Rep. Litvak – Passed
    HB181 Education Funding, Rep. Urquhart – passed (the part about increased funds in some areas)
    Food Tax Bill – passed with the amendment that 2% on unprepared food (groceries) will be cut, saving consumers $70 million.

    Misses:
    SB70 “Envirocare Bill”, Sen. Stephenon – Died (Governor’s veto remains in place)
    SB80 “Toll road” bill, Authorizes the state to enter into “public-private partnerships” to build toll roads – passed (A “miss” because the money from the roads will be used to build more roads)
    SB97 Student Club Amendments, Sen. Buttars – Died
    HB85, Abortion bill, Rep. Kerry Gibson, R-Ogden, allows a judicial bypass option in certain circumstances. In those cases, however, doctors are still required to notify a girl’s parents before ending her pregnancy – passed
    HB181 Education Funding, Rep. Urquhart – passed (I view the part about teacher merit pay as a “miss” and also lack of decreasing class sizes)
    HB304 Voiding Transactions Against Public Policy, Rep Christensen – Died
    HB327 Public Employer Benefit Plans, Rep Christensen – Died
    HB393 Public School Club Amendments, Rep. Tilton – Died
    Legislators giving themselves a $10/day pay raise beginning next January

    This is not a complete list, by any means, but one that addresses the issues I followed most closely. My “misses” list is much longer than my “hits” list. Today’s Deseret news has a consolidated list of “Winners and Losers”.

    I have stated before in this forum that I feel our legislators did not make good use of our time by virtue of the fact that there were bills on morality (not a governemnt issue, in my opinion), very little time spent on discussing and passing legislation for human services, avoidance by the legislators to hear public testimony from both sides of many issues (ignoring those who were prepared to testify in opposition to bills), and way too much time is spent in debate. By the latter, I”ll give an example: As a result of my observations of the House on Wednesday, and by viewing live session videos and archived session videos, there is too much time wasted by allowing legislators to stand up and make statements like “I think this is a good bill and I support it”, or “I think this is a bad bill and I don’t support it”. There is no need to make statements like that unless they preface a persuasive side of an issue. Stating support or non-support is not debate.

    It has been interesting for me to follow this year’s session. The unresolved bills will be addressed in special sessions which I am sure to follow and on which I will provide reports and commentary.

    Hill Happenings

    Yesterday’s Utah Legislative Report Summary
    Articles in published in today’s Utah newspapers about Yesterday’s Utah Legislature news:

    Salt Lake Tribune
    Legislative briefs
    Utah Legislature 2006: To be continued–Surplus challenge: In a ‘stressful session,’ the lawmakers lower food tax, stumble on income tax cut

  • (Includes a pdf document on taxes and budget)
    Real scores on tax to help build stadium: Hotel industry doesn’t like that most of Salt Lake County’s share of the tax will be shipped to Sandy
    Lawmakers follow through with cutting grocery tax by 2 percent: No income tax reform: Time runs out as reluctant lawmakers worry about eliminating certain credits and deductions
    Hate crimes law: After 8 years of trying, a compromise sails through
    Schools get funding bump: The 10.6 percent increase includes a raise for teachers but no change in class sizes
    Law paves the way for private and public alliance–Users pay: Proponents say the deal will make for better roads because motorists will be treated as valued customers

    Deseret News
    Winners and losers
    2006 Legislature: Finished — for now: Nerves fray in scramble to wrap up
    Lack of civility mars session–Some lawmakers show a mean streak with public
    Hate-crimes bill is approved: Senate vote is unanimous; Litvack remembers Suazo
    Key education bills
    Schools get 6% funding hike: Per-student spending is given its highest increase since 1991
    Highlights of this year’s funding for education
    Science ed bill sees defeat: Senate OKs bill to allow cities to create school districts
    State surplus turns into fight over divvying up the budget
    3 get-tough measures on immigration fall short: Bill to halt in-state college tuition dies in House panel
    Ethics reform slams into a big brick wall: Measures falter — despite public opinion surveys
    Immigration bills that didn’t survive the 2006 Legislature
    Public right to records unscathed: GRAMA emerges from session ‘alive and kicking’
    Government Records Access and Management Act
    USTAR may be a costly victory for higher ed
    Penalties boosted for identity theft, sex abuse, other crimes
    Municipalities flex their muscles: But despite wins, many leaders left with bad taste
    Lawmakers OK bill that could bring toll roads to Utah
    2006 legislation on transportation
    Vetoed environmental measure dead
    Legislators back strong parental rights: Critics fear bills could actually hurt some minors
    Was Medicaid the top loser?
    2006 Legislature on crime and criminals
    Measures that have an impact on local government in state