Tag Archives: 2006 legislature

SB 70

As expected, Utah Gov. Huntsman vetoed SB 70, the “Envirocare” bill that would permit lawmakers to override a veto on passed bills aimed at blocking hazardous waste disposal facilities, including those that handle radioactive materials. This was the governor’s first veto of the year.

Gov. Huntsman stated that the bill would incrementally weaken the governor’s ability to protect Utah’s image and environment, as well as the health and safety of its 2.5 million residents. He added that he had pledged to resist efforts to turn the state into “a radioactive dumping ground.”
“Consistent with that pledge,” he concluded, “I cannot consent to a provision that, in my opinion, would potentially lead to the proliferation of radioactive waste-disposal facilities within our state.”

Today will be the day that lawmakers will decide whether or not they have the 2/3 votes necessary to carry out the override. If the veto is overridden, lawmakers will then have the power to allow sites to be established or expand regardless of the governor’s position on the issue.

Last night a crowd of about 50 citizens braved the elements for a glow-stick rally held on the capitol plaza. (The weather was horrible. I had planned to attend but didn’t due to the weather. I will be attending tonight’s rally.) The rally was held to voice opposition to SB 70 and support the governor’s veto.

They called SB70 a special interest legislation aimed at helping EnergySolutions (formerly Envirocare of Utah) get a license to double in size over Huntsman’s objections. And they noted that six commercial garbage sites have been approved without any quarrel about the approval process. The question only came
up when politically powerful Envirocare had an expansion request in the works and Huntsman said he would reject it.
Mary Ellen Navas, of Sandy, told the group 84 percent of Utahns oppose more and more radioactive waste from coming to the state but lawmakers were “disconnected” from their constituents on the issue.
She said any decisions to add waste ought to require “the utmost scrutiny,” as current law allows.
“We hold our children’s future dear, and we would never sacrifice their future to special interests,” she said. “We want extreme caution when it comes to any new waste coming to Utah.”

Last day of legislature

Today is the last official day of the 2006 Legislative Session in Utah.

Today lawmakers will be facing decision-making on these issues:
House

  • how to manage the proposed tax cut, including the $70 million for an income tax reduction, $70 million for a reduction of the sales tax on food, and $20 million for business tax cuts
  • student clubs
  • toll roads
  • redevelopment agency regulations
    Senate

  • reduction in the sales tax on food
  • hate-crime laws
  • funding for the Real Salt Lake soccer stadium

    According to the Deseret News report, what is likely not to receive funding:

  • dental and vision benefits for Medicaid recipients
  • reducing the state’s disability waiting list
  • targeted education programs, especially all-day kindergar- ten

    Regarding the $9 billion fiscal budget:
    The Executive Appropriations Committee approved an additional $100 million in spending Tuesday. But negotiations continue between Senate and House majority Republicans over some $250 million that is expected to go toward tax cuts ($160 million) and roads ($90 million.)
    Senate Democrats attempted Tuesday evening to boost funding for human services needs. But in what Sen. Ed Mayne, D-West Valley, described as “a shame on us,” all of the Democrats’ amendments failed, and the supplemental funding bill eventually passed the Senate 21-5.
    There were also approximately $500,000 in fiscal note bills funded Tuesday by the Executive Appropriations Committee.
    Primarily small expenditures, those fiscal note bills included a $22,500 raise for Lt. Gov. Gary Herbert, $100,000 for an additional child pornography enforcement officer, $93,000 for underage drinking prevention, and $50,000 for translation services at the Center for Multi-Cultural Health.
    There is $20 million remaining in one-time funds that have not been claimed. The Senate and House will each receive $1.5 million to fund some of their own projects.
    The final $17 million will probably go to either the Rainy Day Fund, which the House Republican caucus supports, or to roads, which the Senate caucus supports.
    Some House members fear the government is growing too rapidly and they want to save the cash.
    According to budget numbers released to the Deseret Morning News, the state’s two main funds — the General Fund and the Uniform School Fund — will grow by 9.6 percent for the 2006-2007 budget, which starts July 1. That would most likely exceed a statutory cap on growth, which is tied to population and inflation increases.

  • Hill Happenings

    Yesterday’s Utah Legislative Report Summary
    Articles in published in today’s Utah newspapers about Yesterday’s Utah Legislature news:

    Salt Lake Tribune
    Legislative briefs
    Fight looms over waste authority: Lawmakers to try overriding guv’s veto of bill giving them a final say
    Move to suspend driver licenses fails–HB83: Even with revision to allow for travel to work and school, the Senate rejects the measure
    Utah poor get no help for teeth, vision trouble–
    Managing money: Proposals to increase funding for disabled residents and research of birth defects also failed as the legislative session neared its end

    Attempt to eliminate medical coverage stalls: Cutoff of lawmakers’ benefits faces long odds
    House does 360 on smoking ban–Wrangling: At first the bill would let club patrons light up, but not people on playgrounds; finally lawmakers say no to smoky clubs
    Effort to make e-mail private dropped: Lawmakers’ correspondence becomes public when printed
    Rules for handling developers are OK’d
    S.L. County questions the loyalty and ethics of Tetris lobbyist firm–Triple dipping: The company is being paid by Real Salt Lake, as well as Sandy and the county
    Governor leads immigration push: 13 more join reform call: State leaders urge U.S. to create guest-worker plan and build Western prison
    Eco-groups seek legal role in regulation: Utah Supreme Court: Justices to decide when such groups should be allowed to have legal standing to fight permits
    Money for schools, with a catch: Teachers’ pay becomes dependent on test scores under the new HB181
    Court clarifies kids’ rights on stand–Man’s convictions stick: Justices rule parent can be with child even if they are a potential witness in the same case as the child

    Deseret News
    No question on food tax – Opinion
    Huntsman vetoes bill on disposal of nuclear waste
    Lawmakers face huge legislative logjam today
    Legislators decide to pack it in after session: Several planning to retire or run for different office
    Lawmakers change smoking ban
    Final push for USTAR
    Lobbying firm’s actions not yet a problem, officials say: S.L. County’s Crockett says he isn’t on ‘jihad’ against Tetris
    Pared-down measure on records access OK’d
    A child-support bill tied to drivers’ licenses fails
    Plan letting state dump comp fund advances
    Senate OKs longer terms for repeat sex offenders
    Street-racing legislation zooms through House

    Abortion Bill: Minors will continue to be at risk if this passes

    The Utah Senate voted down a proposed amendment on abortion (proposed by Sen. Scott McCoy) that would have helped protect at risk minors. The senate gave preliminary approval to the original bill, required that physicians seek parental consent before performing abortions on minors. (The bill is on hold pending a funding measure.)

    The current law in Utah, in place since 1974, requires parental notification prior to abortions being performed on minors. The proposed amendment would have waived that noficiation process to minors deemed at risk in the home by abuse.

    Sen. Patrice Arent, D-South Cottonwood, proposed a similar amendment when HB85 was before the Senate Judiciary and Criminal Justice Committee. Monday, Arent said the change takes into account real-world situations.
    “I think it makes sense for those narrow situations where you don’t want to have that girl harmed further,” she said.

    Utah has an “abstinence only” curricula as part of the health classes that have sex ed as a unit in them. Only the issue of abstinence can be taught. Not even other birth control measures may be mentioned. This does not stop minors from having sex. This bill on abortion will not stop minors from seeking abortions. Just a few weeks ago Salt Lake City Weekly ran a feature on minors crossing borders to get abortions because of the laws in Utah. This bill, if passed, will only continue to exascerbate that issue and force minors in abusive situations to seek help out of state.

    Death of the Evolution Bill

    The “Origins of Life” Bill introduced by Rep. Chris Buttars failed to survive in the Utah House.

    The bill would have required the State Board of Education to establish curriculum requirements stressing that the scientific theory about the origin of species and evolution is not empirically proven.
    “Nobody can empirically prove or disprove the theory, and the bill makes a very clear statement as to how I believe we ought to instruct students,” said Rep. Jim Ferrin, R-Orem, the bill’s House sponsor.

    But legislators in the House said they were concerned about singling out the theory of evolution and stepping on what could be the State Board of Education’s turf.
    House Majority Whip Steve Urquhart, R-St. George, amended the bill deleting all language save two lines that reinforced the state board’s role in establishing scientific instruction.
    The amended bill failed on a 28-46 vote, and there were no indications that it would be revived.

    Chris Buttars’ comments:
    “There are a number of influential legislators who believe you evolved from an ape,” Buttars said following the vote. “I didn’t.”

    Republican Rep. LaVar Christensen, stated that SB96 was a “nod toward the almighty.”
    This bill is a small gesture but one that leaves the door open for people to affirm what is in their own constitution, referring to the preamble of the Utah Constitution, which includes the phrase: “Grateful to Almighty God for life and liberty.”

    Opponents to the bill questioned why the state would single out one theory when the scientific community disagrees on dozens of others.
    “Aren’t we in a reverse way endorsing all other theories, because this is the only one we are saying ‘be careful with this one?’ ” asked Rep. Scott Wyatt, R-Logan.
    Rep. Stephen Urquhart, R-St. George, led the charge to defeat the bill, saying he didn’t understand how science contradicted faith.
    “I did not talk about faith, but it has been talked about several times and it’s obvious that’s why we singled out one theory,” he said.
    Urquhart successfully gutted the bill, leaving only one bland sentence that read: “The State Board of Education shall establish curriculum requirements relating to scientific instruction.”

    The news of the dead evolution bill nationwide reached:
    Houston Chronicle
    New York Times
    The Mercury News (San Jose)
    WTVM in Columbus, GA

    Hill Happenings

    Yesterday’s Utah Legislative Report Summary
    Articles in published in today’s Utah newspapers about Yesterday’s Utah Legislature news:

    Salt Lake Tribune
    Legislative briefs
    Bill on evolution proves unfit to survive: House forces changes in Buttars’ proposal, then fails to pass it anyway
    Educators withhold judgment on budget–Grade pending: A $20 million funding increase appears likely, but some key proposals lack support
    Soccer lobbyist works for all sides: Conflict? A councilman wonders how Tetris can represent S.L. County, Sandy and Real Salt Lake
    Rallying for Their Rights: Teens denounce proposed gay-club ban–GAY-STRAIGHT ALLIANCES; SB97: The House has yet to vote on the bill
    E-mail access restriction in trouble
    $2M request bypasses public
    Panel OKs subsidy for This Is the Place Heritage Park

    Lawmakers adopt measure to protect physicians’ apologies–MALPRACTICE SUITS
    Protests disrupt budget meeting: ‘Dental! Dental!’ Benefit again on chopping block
    Senate: Incestuous dad knows best: Lawmakers block exception from abortion consent bill
    Senators want the people’s advice on taxes–Next election: The ‘advisory vote’ would pit grocery-levy relief against money for highways and education
    ‘Natural family’ resolution foes take stage in Kanab–Hearing: A documentary filmmaker will be on hand as opponents address the City Council tonight
    Huntsman pushing immigration reform–Governors meeting: He and Arizona’s chief want colleagues to send a resolution to Congress

    Deseret News
    Huntsman tackling immigration:He wants West’s governors to back new national policy
    Food tax may go before Utah voters
    Possible ballot question on Food Tax
    Amended evolution measure dies in Utah House
    Records access bill hits a snag in the Senate
    Abortion bill gets approval
    Activists rally for gay rights in ‘family state’–Groups use 1,000 paper cranes to send message of tolerance
    Child-care license restriction gets initial Senate approval
    Fee-waiver legislation gets preliminary Senate approval
    ‘Lori Hacking bill’ passes unanimously in first round

    Today’s visit to the Capitol

    So I took my students to the capitol today. Well, we got there on time. The kids were amazed at how “different” they looked from everyone else – you know, school kid attire vs. legislator attire. We got seated in the observer gallery of the House Chamber (we decided on the House vs. the Senate) and waited. And waited. And waited.

    We learned that the legislature sessions do not start on time. This we found out after sitting for nearly half and hour and complaining, when someone in the room stated “oh, they almost always start 1/2 hour late.”
    Great. So it turned out that by the time the floor session started, my students got to hear about 15 minutes of debate and voting.

    Next year I’ll be sure to take them on the Youth in Legislature Day (I totally missed the boat on that one this year).

    I stayed at the capitol for almost the rest of the session today. Here are some of the bills voted on:

    SB 160 – Physician Licensing: Allows temporary licensing for up to 1 year for new physicians to the state (if licensed in another state) until they get their Utah license. Passed.

    SB 174 – In State tuition for the National Guard: Clarificaion of exisitn gpractice. Passed.

    SB 84 – Non-Profit Entity Amendments: motion added to make non-profits more accountable. Passed.

    SB 71 – Consumer Credit Protection: Provides protection against indentiy theft with consumer reporting agencies. Puts more control in consumer’s hands. Passed.

    SB 54 – Revenue Flow from Speeding Violations: Would give 1/2 money generated from speeding citations in rural areas with only state roads but where municipal law enforcement issues citations to the state. Failed.

    Well, it was…interesting.

    Today’s lesson in civics

    Today the History teacher at my school and I are taking a group of our students (11th and 12th graders) to observe today’s floor session of the Utah Senate. I am anxious to hear the students’ perceptions. I faciliate the learning of this group of students in our school’s Service Learning Class. It is this class time that will be used for the field trip. Our history teacher will be spending the class time at school today preparing them for the trip by reveiwing the procedure of the Senate and House sessions and what bills have been introduced and debated this year. We will be spending one hour observing the Utah Senate.

    After the session, I will be joining supporters of the GLBT community in a peaceful demonstration just outside the Senate building (4pm) to voice opposition to the school clubs bill by Senator Buttars. I have mentioned the demonstration to students in case they want to observe yet another way that citizens make their voices heard.

    Hill Happenings

    Articles in published in today’s Utah newspapers about Utah Legislature and related news:

    Salt Lake Tribune
    Public funding for state’s community colleges on decline–Not just Utah: Students are paying more to offset inadequate public funding for community colleges
    Achievement gap attacked–Batch of legislation would help minority students catch up with whites

    Deseret News
    Don’t expect Legislature to police ‘drops’ – Opinion
    Parental choice in education overdue – Opinion
    Utah woos Harvard researchers
    Toll-road bill nears OK, but opposition building
    Alpine is reviewing its policy on clubs
    Ovations, not jeers, for hate-crimes bill:Litvack’s new approach to divisive issue pays off

    Hill Happenings

    Articles in published in today’s Utah newspapers about Utah Legislature news:

    Salt Lake Tribune
    Legislative clock ticking on controversial bills–
    Three-day rush: With the session set to end Wednesday, hundreds of proposals are pending

    Lawmaker says pawnshops not abetting thieves
    Bad rap? Lockhart’s amendment would let the stores sell items without a waiting period

    Deseret News
    Deadlock makes for a wild legislative session – Opinion
    Huntsman brings out ‘big stick’: He’s ready to use veto, twist arms
    Most oppose records restriction
    Increase in roads funding favored
    Cities may soon control schools